For whatever reason, Providence has had absolutely no success of recent when traveling to Milwaukee to take on the Golden Eagles of Marquette. It’s gotten to the point where I’d rather play the Connecticut Huskies at their place and feel better about a chance of victory there solely because of how poorly Providence has played against Marquette.
Yes, the Golden Eagles have been a perennial Top 25-ish program over the past few years under Shaka Smart, but it just seems like whenever Providence travels there, you can chalk up the game to a loss. The last win by the Friars on the road against Marquette was in 2019-2020 by one point. Since then, the Golden Eagles have made easy work of the Friars on their home court, winning by an average of 20.4 points. Yes, that stat is accurate as I checked the numbers in few times out of shock. Providence of recent lays down on the mat whenever they go on the road to Wisconsin, but I’m hopeful this year will turn the tide.
The fall of the Golden Eagles this year is shocking due to just how drastically they’ve fallen off the map in college basketball, but it isn’t exactly surprising if you follow recruiting, the transfer portal, and how Shaka operates the two. Shaka Smart is a big believer in building a culture through roster continuity and building through high school recruiting exclusively, and the last few years have shown him to be directionally accurate in this approach despite the NCAA heading in the complete opposite direction.
He is Dabo Swinney like in his refusal to add players via the portal, with the belief that his ability to find players in high school and develop them throughout their tenure at Marquette trumps plugging holes in the transfer portal via one year mercenaries. While I am personally a huge advocate of “majoring in high school recruiting, minoring in the portal” and appreciate the intent of what Shaka is trying to do, it is malfeasance to not at least look to add 1 or 2 players per offseason in the transfer portal. There are without a doubt guys in the portal that would fit seamlessly with the Marquette culture. Not at least entertaining the idea of augmenting your already strong roster with a portal player or two is managing a team with one hand tied behind your back, and that is a choice Smart is actively making.
Marquette has flamed out in the NCAA tournament over the past few years, and I’m certain Golden Eagles fans are frustrated with Shaka’s stubbornness in not adding a piece or two to put these Top 25 rosters over the top to be legitimate national title contenders. That’s not hyperbole either, by the way. Adding 1 or 2 immediate impact portal guys to the Marquette rosters over the past few years that had Oso, Kolek, Jones, etc. could have made them a contender to win it all, but Shaka just outright refuses to add via the portal.
By not adding any portal guys, you essentially have to nail every high school evaluation, which is an impossibility. That hasn’t happened for Smart, and this year is the culmination of not adding portal players and the talent recruits out of high school not making the year over year leap we’ve come to know with the Golden Eagles.
Marquette is currently 6-13 and last in the Big East at 1-7. If Providence is going to pick off the Golden Eagles at their place, this year is the year to do it.
We preview the game below and what the Friars need to do to win on the road.
Continue reading “House of Horrors No More? Marquette Providence Preview”